Previous
articles in this series introduced the topic of advanced composite materials
(ACMs) as structures of fibers bound into a solid matrix, and examined both
fiber and matrix materials more closely. Those articles, despite their length,
have barely scratched the surface of this topic, and it should be apparent
from this that ACMs represent a very highly specialized technology. Indeed,
certain applications of ACMs require very strict adherence to principles
and procedures if sound, reliable structural components are to be the result.
This article will examine the need for the proper training of people who
build, repair, maintain, or design the ACM materials and structures upon
which we depend.
Most
people are 'familiar' with ACMs through the 'fiberglass patch kits' that
can be had at any automotive or hardware store. These kits typically come
with a yard or so of light-weight, random-orientation glass fiber fabric,
a can of a simple polyester resin, and a small tube of cream hardener. In
use, one prepares a quantity of the resin by adding a small amount of the
hardener to initiate the polymerization reaction. A piece of the fiberglass
fabric is then mixed into or wetted in the activated resin, and the resulting
wad of 'goop' is worked into a rough shape or form over a hole in some automotive
bodywork or elsewhere. Once this patch has cured, it is typically then coerced
into a more desirable final shape through the use of grinders, files, sandpaper,
scrapers, or any other tool that the repairer may find close to hand and
deem as being worth a try. A thin coat of polymer putty may then be applied
and smoothed out to fill any irregularities in the fiberglass patch. A coat
or two of spray paint then completes the job.
The 'fiberglass
patch kit' has been around for a long time. It has been refine d somewhat,
and it is pretty much 'fool proof' in that anyone can use one and obtain
quite satisfactory results. Indeed, such a patch job, carried out with some
care, may last for many years. The person who performed the work may be secure
in the belief that he or she now understands how to work with ACMs.
It is a false security.
Picture this scenario: The young person who did that simple patch job,
and perhaps a few other patch jobs as well, subsequently finds employment
at a small local aircraft maintenance facility. The job entails cleaning
small private aircraft, and assisting the owner/operator of the facility
with minor repairs. As these repairs are typically carried out on low-performance
private aircraft constructed with thin sheet metal skins, the repairs are
fairly simple and straightforward. But then one day the owner of the facility
secures a repair job on a helicopter that has developed a nasty crack in
the engine intake cowl. He knows two things: he knows that the intake cowl
is made of fiberglass-based composites, so the sheet metal repair techniques
with which he is familiar will not work, and he knows that his helper has
mentioned having carried out fiberglass repairs on many occasions. So the
owner gives the go-ahead, and the helper proceeds with the repair using the
fiberglass patch kit methods he knows. They are pleased to find that the
repair seems to go quite easily. The hard, smooth surface of the intake cowl
allows the woven fiberglass patch cloth to be pressed down very neatly, and
the resin appears to bond very well to the surface. The cured patch is still
a little rough around the edges, but with a little extra fine sanding and
some glazing putty, it will look as good as new...
Or how about this scenario? An outdoors enthusiast wants to build a
custom canoe. Some research has revealed the incredible impact resistance
and light weight of aramid (Kevlar) fabric, so the do-it-yourselfer decides
to build his c anoe using woven aramid with an easy-to-use polyester resin.
Some time later, the new canoe looks great and is ready to go on the water
in the rock-strewn northern rivers and lakes that the outdoorsman likes to
explore...
And here's one more scenario to consider. A worker in a factory that
produces small aircraft of composite construction is assigned the task of
fastening cross members in the tail sections of the aircraft as they proceed
along the production line. He has been taught the proper way to attach the
cross members using the correct fasteners, and he carries out this task both
well and unquestioningly. For some reason, his supply of the proper fasteners
runs out, but being a bright fellow, he realizes that there are other techniques
for fastening things together. He thinks for a moment or two, assembling
the components of another technique from what he knows, then diligently sets
to work. In place of the fasteners he is supposed to use, he now drills several
pilo t holes in the cross members and secures them in place using expanding
head or 'pop' rivets. His new method quickly has the members tightly fastened
in place, and the production line moves along again with barely an interruption.
In these three scenarios, the resolutions may seem harmless enough to
the untrained individual, but there is one facet of ACM structures that can
not be overlooked or forgotten for a single moment: failure to work strictly
within the principles that govern the performance of ACM structures is a
fatal mistake. When dealing with ACM structures, mistakes are not forgiven.
Each of these scenarios involve serious flaws that WILL result in the failure
of the structure, with the loss of life being a near certain result.
In the first scenario, the repair procedure and materials were totally
inappropriate. The engine intake cowl of the helicopter was indeed made with
fiberglass, but in a high-performance thermosetting epoxy resin. This is
entirely inco mpatible with the polyester resin 'patch kit' material that
was used for the repair. Nor was the patching process used in any way appropriate
to rebuilding the internal structure of the cowl itself. In effect, the patch
was only stuck over the crack temporarily, like a band-aid, and was not bonded
into the ACM structure of the cowl. At some point, most likely under full
engine load in flight, the patch would have separated from the cowl and been
drawn directly into the turbines of the helicopter engine. The engine would
have been instantly and completely destroyed, and the helicopter would have
crashed killing at least everyone on board at the time.
The outdoorsman's canoe, in the second scenario, would have worked out
very well, at least for a time. While the aramid fiber would indeed have
offered excellent resistance to impacts against rocks, the low-performance
matrix would have become cracked and damaged immediately, allowing the aramid
fibers to come into contact with the water. Some further research would have
revealed that such contact would allow the aramid fibers to 'wick up' as
much as twelve times their own weight of water. Where this happens, the composite
structure is ruined and will require frequent repair at best. At the worst,
the canoe would become heavier and heavier, losing its designed weight balance
and perhaps dumping its occupants into the freezing waters of some cold northern
lake.

The
third scenario also seems to have an acceptable solution, but in reality
it does not. ACMs and ACM structures are surprisingly fragile when exposed
to forces they were not designed to accommodate, and like all such materials
they are especially vulnerable to forces acting across the fibers rather
than along the length of the fibers. The worker's "new" technique of fastening
the cross members will work extremely well with other materials, such as
sheet metal, but is completely unacceptable for joining structures made from
ACMs. Examination of the members that had been fastened in this way revealed
that the sideways pressures exerted against the composite material by the
rivet heads as they were set into place had fractured and cracked both fibers
and matrix at every instance. Under load, as in flight, the structures would
have failed catastrophically. Every one of the airplanes in which this method
of fastening the cross members had been used would have crashed.
All three of these scenarios are more than merely object lessons in
an article. They are in fact actual true incidents that, fortunately, were
caught in time by trained personnel who happened to spot the problems. The
cured patch on the helicopter engine cowl was grasped lightly by the corner
and unceremoniously jerked away by a composites expert when the young worker
asked if his patch work was good; the outdoorsman was informed of the problems
associated with aramid fiber and water, and was advised to use carbon fiber
with a tough epoxy resin instead ; the damage caused by the faulty fastening
technique was spotted and reported by a visiting composites expert who just
happened to be walking through the plant to meet someone at the time.
Unfortunately, such incidents occur all too frequently due to a lack
of proper training. People who are trusted by others to carry out certain
tasks fall victim to the trap of simply not realizing that ACMs are completely
different from any other materials that they have ever worked with. The basic
rules that apply to all of those other materials do not apply to ACMs. Proper
training and a good appreciation of how ACMs work are essential to working
with and applying them successfully. Proper training saves time, money, reputations,
and even lives.
How much money can proper training save? A simple example, again taken
from real life, offers a good indication. Carbon fiber "2 by 2" twill has
become a very popular material for custom compo sites work, as much for its
visual appeal as for its structural properties. A trainee at an international
training facility once recounted his experience with a venture to produce
custom decorative truck bumpers from this material. He required a mold in
which to lay up the resin and fabric to form the new bumpers, and had proceeded
to take a "splash" mold from a standard bumper. He used the correct materials
and laid down strip after strip of unidirectional glass fiber and resin to
capture the exact shape of the bumper. Several hours later, he removed his
new mold, which immediately twisted out of shape. He then obtained a different
resin in the mistaken belief that his choice of materials had been incorrect,
and repeated the entire mold-making procedure. The results were the same,
an unusable twisted mold. When the trainee learned about the principles and
effects of fiber orientation, he realized (and said as much) that he had
thrown away literally thousands of dollars in just th ose two mold-making
attempts. Had he known about these effects beforehand through proper training,
his first attempt would have been entirely successful.
This is a "low end" example. Imagine the result had this been a "high
end" operation producing a specific structural component for an aircraft.
Replacing an advanced composite wing or tail component on a commercial passenger
aircraft can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Imagine the cost in each
of the three above scenarios had the errors gone unnoticed. Lost money...
lost lives.
The fields of advanced composite materials and the associated technologies
are some of the fastest growing. Fiber and resin materials are becoming more
and more sophisticated each day, as new materials and new applications are
developed. Yet, no matter how advanced these fields become, the basic principles
of ACMs remain the same. The principles are easily learned, and the knowledge
can pay for itself many times over, regardless of wheth er the person who
employs that knowledge is working in automotive, watercraft, or other industries.
Aerospace applications are in a category of their own, and the value of proper
training with ACMs is much higher.
Certifications for Aerospace Applications:
Aerospace
applications are covered by very strict regulations. Aircraft maintenance
engineers and technicians in Canada, the United States, and around the world,
are required to obtain accredited training from government-approved training
facilities. Such training is a requirement of qualification that is reflected
in the license rating that authorizes an AME or AMT to carry out maintenance
and repairs to advanced composites structures in aerospace applications.
There is a line of accountability in industries that make use of advanced
composites structures. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the aerospace
industry, in which meticulous histories are maintained for every single component
of commercial aircraft, including the name of every person who has provided
repair and maintenance service. The same regulations that specify approved
training for AMEs and AMTs also specify how materials used in aerospace ACM
applications must be handled. Such materials must be certified to a level
of performance, with registered dates of expiration. Factors such as storage
temperature and humidity, "out time", and limits of exposure to light are
covered by regulations, and documentation of all regulated factors is required.
Approved training in advanced composites methodologies and techniques
is provided at only a few locations in North America, but may be had anywhere
in the world. It is usually advantageous for ACM workers from foreign countries
to travel to Canada or the United States in order to obtain quality training
for working with ACMs.

In
Canada, approved training is offered at certain colleges as part of their
regular AME and AMT programs, open to both Canadian and foreign students
(who will pay a significantly higher tuition for these programs than will
a Canadian citizen). Shorter programs of intensive training may also be
undertaken at privately owned facilities that also reach out to the world-wide
market with non-preferential tuition rates. The foremost privately-owned
Canadian facility for ACM training is Renaissance Aeronautics Associates
Incorporated (RAA), with headquarters in London, Ontario, Canada. This company
became the first privately owned training facility in North America to be
approved by both the Canadian federal transport ministry (Transport Canada)
and by the Canadian Aviation Maintenance Council (CAMC). Training programs
delivered by RAA are geared specifically to the practical aspects of working
with ACMs. They are offered both on-site in London, Toronto, Montreal, and
Vancouver facilities, and off-site anywhere in the world.
In
the United States of America, training for work with ACMs is also provided
by both academic institutions and by private training facilities. Several
colleges and universities offer advanced composites training programs, notably
University of Missouri - Rolla and Cerritos College. Abaris Training is the
leading private training provider in the United States, offering a selection
of courses designed to provide an in-depth understanding of theoretical and
engineering aspects of ACMs. Abaris Training has its headquarters in Reno,
Nevada, and operates a second campus at Griffin, Georgia. The company now
also offers off-site training world-wide.
There are a number of other training facilities and companies in North
America and elsewhere, specializing in various aspects of advanc ed composites
training. With apologies, a comprehensive description of all of these fine
institutions and their respective services is well beyond the scope of this
article.
In general, courses of study offered by private and academic institutions
like RAA and Canadore College (in Canada) and Abaris Training and University
of Missouri - Rolla (in the United States), must meet the standards of any
particular country in order to satisfy the requirements for qualification
of AMEs and AMTs to work with composite materials in aerospace industries
within that country. Additionally, air carriers will require foreign AMEs
and AMTs to be trained to the standards that exist in the carrier's home
nation. Thus, for example, training for an AMT who will be licensed by the
government of Argentina must be consistent with the AMT licensing standards
of Argentina, and work carried out in Argentina on , say, a Boeing 747 belonging
to Air France must conform to the specifications and standards employed
by Air France.
Conclusion:
It has been the object of this series of articles to open the reader's
eyes to the vast potential of advanced composite materials, and to careers
working with these amazing materials. The potential for the world of ACMs
is one that has no bounds, as new materials and applications are discovered
and developed literally every day. Where those materials and careers may
take us in reality can only be glimpsed in our imaginations, and this series
of articles has barely even scratched the surface of this huge topic. But
there are rules ands principles that must be strictly followed when designing
and applying ACMs and ACM structures. These can only be learned effectively
through proper training.
Useful Links:
For further information you may view the following useful links:
Renaissance Aeronautics Associates Inc.
http://www.raacomposites.com
Abaris Training
http://www.abaristraining.com
Canadore College
http://www.canadorec.on.ca
University of Missouri – Rolla
http://www.umt.edu
Cerritos College
http://www.cerritos.edu
Articles and Columns By Richard:
Radon, A Rare Element
Chemical Weapons
A Four Part Series
What is pH?
Composite Materials
How Can A Bullet-proof Vest Stop A Bullet?
|